Chapter 9 : Investing in Funds

When considering fund investing, applying Benjamin Graham's value investing philosophy, there are several important questions to consider carefully.

The answers to these questions will play an important role in your investment decisions.

To become a intelligent investor, also read the article below!

1. Who is Benjamin Graham, author of The Intelligent Investor?

2. Benjamin Graham's Wise Investing Strategies: A Guide for Beginner Investors

3. Benjamin Graham's The intelligent Investor: Inflation and 100 Years of Stock Prices

4. The Average Investor's Portfolio Strategy and The Aggressive Investor's Portfolio Strategy

5. Investing and Market Volatility

1. Questions to ask when selecting a fund

Criteria Likelihood of Excess Returns Avoiding Underperformance Recommended Fund Types
Focus on long-term performance Unlikely, as past performance doesn't guarantee future results. Sustainable investment strategy is crucial. Possible, by prioritizing long-term stability and consistency over short-term gains. N/A
Diversification and valuation Possible, with careful analysis of intrinsic value and diversification, which can mitigate risk. Probable, as diversification and valuation can help avoid underperformance over time. Commingled funds for defensive investors seeking diversification; Open-end funds for those valuing liquidity; No-load funds for low-cost investing.

Applying Benjamin Graham's value investing principles to fund selection provides an important guide to making prudent and well-informed investment decisions.

His philosophy emphasizes an investment approach that emphasizes long-term value and stability, rather than simply relying on past performance.


2. Overall performance of the fund

(1) Historical Background

Analyzing data going back to 1970, we found that compared to the S&P 500 Index, certain 10 funds performed similarly in the first five years, but in the subsequent five years, the performance of these funds outperformed the index. There was also a wide variation in performance within the same fund.

(2) Graham's conclusion

(3) Real-world examples


Fund Summary
Vanguard 500 Index Fund (VFIAX) This fund has a strong track record over the past five years and has outperformed the S&P 500 Index, so there is a good chance that it will continue to perform well in the future.
Fidelity Magellan Fund (FMAGX) This fund has performed well in the past, having excelled in the 1980s and 1990s. However, its performance in recent years has been somewhat lackluster.

However, there is potential for improved performance in the future, depending on changes in the fund manager's strategy or changes in the market environment.
T. Rowe Price Blue Chip Growth Fund (TRBCX) This fund has performed well over the past five-plus years, achieving returns above the market average. This is likely to continue in the future due to the consistency of the investment strategy and the manager's exceptional ability.

(4) Fund Performance Since 1970

Since the 1970s, the fund industry has grown significantly, and a wide variety of investment strategies and products have emerged. Some funds have outperformed the S&P 500 Index over the long term, demonstrating that fund performance is strongly influenced by a fund manager's expertise, investment strategy, and adaptability to market changes.


Decade Market Conditions Fund Performance
The 1980s
  • Decline in interest rates on the bond market
  • Boom in the stock market
  • Strength in technology and consumer stocks
Many funds achieved high returns, often averaging more than 12% per year.
The 1990s
  • Rapid growth of technology stocks, particularly internet-related stocks
Many funds achieved annualized returns of 15-20% or more during this period, especially those focused on technology stocks.
The 2000s
  • Dot-com bubble burst and 2008 financial crisis
Overall poor performance, but recovery in the late 2000s, with some funds achieving annualized returns of 5-10%.
The 2010s
  • Continued low interest rate environment
  • General upturn in equity markets
  • Strong growth in technology stocks
Many funds achieved annualized returns of 10-15% or more, with tech-focused funds remaining strong.
The 2020s
  • Market volatility due to the COVID-19 pandemic
  • Quick market recovery, led by technology stocks
Performance divergence, with some funds achieving strong annualized returns of 20% or more, while others underperformed.

3. performance funds

(1) The Manhattan Fund

In 1965, the Manhattan Fund was founded, which made its mark on the investment world by investing in what was then known as high-PER (price-to-earnings ratio) stocks, which were those with high stock price volatility despite paying little or no dividends.

In its early stages, the Manhattan Fund performed remarkably well. For example, when the S&P 500 Index rose 11%, the Manhattan Fund returned 38.6%. But things took a turn for the worse in 1968, when performance fell sharply, much to the dismay of investors.

Stock Price Trend (1965-1968)

(2) The experience and lessons of the Manhattan Fund

The Manhattan Fund's managers were all in their 30s and 40s, and most of them had only experienced the bull market from 1948 to 1968. This lack of experience led to a serious crisis when the fund hit a bear market. This provides a very important lesson in the investment world.

As the French proverb goes, "The more things change, the more they remain the same," emphasizing the importance of basic investment principles that remain constant amidst market changes and uncertainty.


(3) Fidelity Magellan Fund

The Fidelity Magellan Fund was founded in 1963 and rose to prominence, especially when managed by Peter Lynch from 1977 to 1990. During his management, the fund averaged an annualized return of approximately 29%, significantly outperforming the S&P 500 Index over the same period.

Comparison of Peter Lynch's Magellan Fund and S&P 500 Stock Prices


(4) The Magellan Fund's investment strategy

Beyond a "buy and hold" strategy, Peter Lynch favored investing based on a careful analysis of a company's fundamental value and growth potential. He invested wherever he saw value, whether it was in large, mid, or small-cap stocks.

This flexible approach was one of the keys to his ability to achieve high returns in a variety of market conditions.

<1> Peter Lynch's investment principles

Principle Description
1. "Invest in What You Know" Lynch encouraged investors to invest in companies they know and understand well. He advised them to pay attention to products, services, and industries they encounter every day, rather than complex financial models and forecasts.

This stems from his belief that "the best investment ideas often come from our everyday lives."
2. "Include stocks from different categories in your portfolio" Lynch categorized stocks into several categories, including "Slow Growers," "Stalwarts," "Fast Growers," "Asset Plays," "Turnarounds," and "Cyclicals."

He believed that by including these different types of stocks in your portfolio, you can diversify your risk and profit from different phases of the market.
3. "Don't obsess over market timing" Lynch believed that it was impossible to time the market. Instead, he favored a strategy of identifying good companies, buying their shares when they were undervalued, and holding on to them until their value was properly recognized by the market.
4. "Don't be overzealous, be patient" Lynch noted that investors often tend to be too impatient, or overreact to short-term fluctuations in the market.

He advised to pay attention to a company's intrinsic value and long-term growth potential, and emphasized being patient and maintaining a long-term perspective when making investment decisions.

(5) Lessons learned and impact

The success stories of the Fidelity Magellan Fund and Peter Lynch offer a number of important lessons. In particular, they emphasize the importance of sticking to fundamental analysis and maintaining a long-term perspective, even in a complex investment environment.

"Investing is both an art and a science," Lynch said, advising investors to focus on the intrinsic value of a company and not be swayed by short-term market fluctuations.

PEG Ratio Calculator

The Price/Earnings to Growth (PEG) ratio is a valuation metric used in stock analysis. It compares a company's Price/Earnings (P/E) ratio to its annual earnings per share (EPS) growth rate. The PEG ratio is calculated using the formula:

PEG = P/E Ratio / Annual EPS Growth Rate

A PEG ratio of 1 or less is generally considered favorable, indicating that the stock may be undervalued relative to its earnings growth rate.






4. Open-end funds vs. Closed-end funds

(1) Fund Types

Open-End Funds Closed-End Funds

• Open-end funds have a structure that allows investors to join or leave the fund at any time.

• When investors invest money in the fund, the fund issues new units (shares), and when investors want to get their money back, the fund buys units (shares) to return their money.

• The price of a fund is based on its Net Asset Value (NAV), which is calculated daily. No additional premiums or discounts are applied.

• A closed-end fund issues only a fixed number of shares, which are traded on the stock market.

• The price of a closed-end fund is determined by market supply and demand, which may differ from its net asset value (NAV). As a result, a closed-end fund may trade above or below its NAV.


(2) Performance comparison

Performance Period Closed-End Fund Return Open-End Fund Return
1961-1970 9.14% 9.95%
Key Points
  • The closed-end fund returned 9.14%.
  • The open-end fund returned 9.95%.
  • The key point here is the premium added to the open-end fund and the discount at which the closed-end fund trades.

  • For example, if an open-end fund has a net asset value of 100 won, and a premium of 9% is added, the actual purchase price is 109 won. On the other hand, if a closed-end fund trades at about a 20% discount to its net asset value, you can buy a 100 won fund for 80 won.

  • Taking this into account, we can calculate the real return:
    • The real return of an open-end fund should take into account the profit over the purchase price, so ((109 * (1 + 0.0995) - 109) / 109 ≈ 0.0995) (The real return does not change when accounting for the initial premium, but the initial investment cost is higher).
    • For a closed-end fund, ((80 * (1 + 0.0914) - 80) / 80 ≈ 0.0914) (The real rate of return is the same, but the initial investment cost is lower).

  • Therefore, given your real purchasing power, it may be more economical in the long run to choose a closed-end fund with a lower initial investment cost. However, it's also important to understand why closed-end funds trade below their net asset value: the discount rate.

    This discount rate can be caused by a number of factors, including supply and demand imbalances in the market, market perceptions of fund management, and differences in liquidity.
Bank

Chapter 10: Investment advice

Unless you have a close personal relationship, investors should only accept standard advice that is conservative and very simple.

1. Investment Advisory Services and Bank Trust Services

Investment advisory services and bank trust services are the two main paths to reliable income and wealth growth. They are designed to meet the different needs and goals of investors, and each has its own unique approach and advantages.

Here, we'll delve deeper into the key characteristics of these two services and provide specific guidance on which investors may be better suited to each.

Investment Advisory Services Bank Trust Services

Key Features

  • Personalized advice from experts: Investment advisory services provide customized investment strategies based on a thorough analysis of your financial situation, risk appetite, and long-term goals.

    Our experts closely monitor market trends and adjust your portfolio accordingly.

  • Diverse investment opportunities: Investment Advisory Services diversifies your portfolio by offering a range of investment opportunities, including traditional stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, as well as alternative investments.

Who is it right for?

  • Investors who prefer personalized investment advice based on their individual financial situation

  • Investors who want access to a wide range of investment opportunities

Key Features

  • Legal protection: The Bank Trust Service places your assets under a legal trust, which means that your assets are managed under legal protection.

    This can be an important factor, especially when it comes to estate planning or wealth transfer.

  • Conservative investment approach: Bank trust services focus primarily on relatively stable investments, such as government bonds, blue-chip stocks, and index funds.

    They aim for stable returns while protecting the investor's assets.

Who is it right for?

  • Investors who value legal protection while managing their assets with a long-term horizon

  • Investors who prefer a conservative approach to investing

(3) Conclusion: Personalized Choice Matters

Investment advisory services and bank trust services each have unique advantages, and the best choice may depend on an investor's specific needs and circumstances.

Investment advisory services offer a more personalized and flexible approach, while bank trust services may be an ideal choice for investors who value legal protection and stability.

Ultimately, the choice between the two should be based on each investor's financial goals, risk tolerance, and long-term plans.


(4) Additional considerations

Considerations Investment Advisory Services Bank Trust Services
Clarify your financial goals
Investors should be clear about what their financial goals are.

For example, whether they are looking for high returns in the short term or long-term asset growth may determine which service to choose.
  • Personalized advice based on individual financial situation

  • Access to diverse investment opportunities

  • Expert monitoring and portfolio adjustments
  • Legal protection of assets

  • Conservative investment approach

  • Focus on stable returns and asset protection
Assess your risk tolerance
It's also important to assess how much risk you're willing to take with your investments.

Investors who aim for high returns but want to minimize risk may prefer bank trust services.
Consider your long-term plans
You should consider your long-term financial plans and goals when choosing a service.

For example, if you have estate planning or wealth transfer plans, a bank trust service may be more suitable for you.
Recommendations:
Both investment advisory services and bank trust services have their advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice for you will depend on your individual needs and circumstances.

Therefore, it is important to clarify your financial goals, risk tolerance, and long-term plans, and then seek professional advice to choose the service that is best for you.

Before making any investment decisions, it's wise to gather as much information as possible and, if necessary, consult with a professional who can provide financial advice.

With this approach, investors will be able to choose the best investment path that aligns with their financial goals and long-term plans.

(6) Reputable Investment Advisory Services Firms and Bank Trust Services Firms

Bank

<1> Famous investment advisory service firms

Company Overview Strengths
BlackRock
  • One of the largest asset management companies globally

  • Owner of iShares, a global investment site

  • Offers a wide range of investment advisory services, including portfolio management, asset allocation, and risk management

  • Manages a variety of investment products, particularly exchange-traded funds (ETFs)

  • Significant presence in global markets
  • Extensive experience and expertise in asset management

  • Diverse range of investment products

  • Global presence facilitates access to international markets
The Vanguard Group
  • Asset management firm known for cost-effective investment solutions

  • Primarily manages investments as index funds

  • Aims to provide low costs and high returns for individual investors

  • Core value is "for investors," reflecting a client-first approach
  • Focus on minimizing management fees for investors

  • Commitment to putting clients' interests first

  • Emphasis on simplicity and transparency in investment strategies
Fidelity Investments
  • Global asset management firm with strengths in retirement plans and services for individual investors

  • Offers personalized investment advice and a wide range of investment products

  • Utilizes technology to enhance the customer experience and provide transparent services
  • Expertise in retirement planning and services

  • Focus on providing personalized investment advice

  • Integration of technology for efficient and transparent services

<2> Famous Bank Trust Services Companies

Company Overview Strengths
JPMorgan Chase & Co.
  • Holds a leading position in the global financial services industry

  • Offers a wide range of wealth management services

  • Provides wealth management services, including trust services, to help clients achieve their financial goals

  • Gained trust by providing customized trust management solutions, especially for high net worth individuals
  • Extensive experience and expertise in the financial services industry

  • Customized trust management solutions tailored to high net worth individuals

  • Comprehensive wealth management services
Bank of America
  • Merrill Lynch, a division of Bank of America, offers comprehensive bank trust services for individual and corporate clients

  • Provides customized financial planning and wealth management strategies to help clients achieve their financial goals

  • Offers a wide range of wealth management services to meet diverse financial needs
  • Comprehensive bank trust services

  • Customized financial planning and wealth management strategies

  • Diverse range of wealth management services
Citigroup
  • Global bank offering comprehensive wealth management solutions, including investment management, estate planning, charitable giving planning, and trust services

  • Provides clients with tools and resources to create and maintain personalized investment plans
  • Comprehensive wealth management solutions

  • Wide range of financial services

  • Tools and resources for personalized investment planning

2. Investor Relations

Investment information services can help investors assess the intrinsic value of a company and identify discrepancies between price and value that may be caused by market sentiment.

(1) Famous investment information service companies and their characteristics

Financial Information Providers Overview Key Features
Bloomberg
  • Provides a wide range of financial data, analytical tools, and news

  • Terminal services are highly regarded among financial professionals worldwide

  • Deep data analysis is essential for assessing a company's intrinsic value

  • Offers real-time information on market trends, economic news, and company reports
  • Deep data analysis tools

  • Real-time market trends and news

  • Terminal services widely used by financial professionals
Reuters
  • Provides extensive financial information and global news coverage

  • Helps investors understand global market trends and economic conditions

  • Offers economic indicators and expert analysis for assessing industry and company impacts
  • International news and financial information

  • Insight into global market trends and economic conditions

  • Economic indicators and expert analysis
Morningstar
  • Primarily known for in-depth analysis of funds and stocks

  • Analysis helps investors assess intrinsic value, financial strength, profitability, growth prospects, etc.

  • Independent investment research organization with useful ratings and reviews for comparing funds and stocks
  • Fund and stock analysis

  • Assessment of intrinsic value and other key metrics

  • Independent ratings and reviews

(2) Benjamin Graham's perspective.

In Benjamin Graham's view, investment information service companies help investors evaluate the intrinsic value of companies and make investment decisions that are irrational in the market. This allows investors to focus on long-term value and not be swayed by the short-term volatility of the market.

However, Graham also emphasized the importance of investors making independent judgments based on their own research and analysis, rather than being swayed by market emotions.

In this regard, the data and analytical tools provided by investment information service firms are an important resource, but investors must interpret and apply this information to their own investment philosophy and strategy.


(3) Tips for utilizing investment information: Benjamin Graham's Perspective


Guidelines for Value Investing

  1. Analyze intrinsic value: Utilize data and analytics from investment information services to calculate the intrinsic value of a company.

    Analyze financial statements, profitability metrics, growth prospects, and more to determine if a company is undervalued relative to its market price.

  2. Consider multiple perspectives: Gather information from multiple investment information service firms to obtain diverse opinions and data. This balanced approach enhances investment decisions.

  3. Maintain a long-term perspective: Focus on long-term investment goals rather than short-term market fluctuations. Use short-term volatility as an opportunity to invest based on intrinsic value.

  4. Develop your own investment principles: Utilize information and tools from investment information service firms to evaluate companies and establish your own investment principles. Stay consistent with these principles and avoid being influenced by market noise.

  5. Manage your emotions: Recognize and control the impact of emotions in the investment decision-making process. Base decisions on objective data and analysis rather than fear and greed.

From Benjamin Graham's perspective, investment information service firms provide investors with useful information and tools, but it's how they use them that matters.

By interpreting and applying the information provided to their own investment philosophy and strategy, investors can make more informed investment decisions. In the end, through continuous learning and emotional management, investors can succeed in the markets.


3. Advice from Securities Firms

(1) Characteristics and roles of global securities firms

Global securities firms play a pivotal role in the financial markets and provide a wide range of financial services to investors. These firms are widely recognized internationally, such as Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan Chase, and others, and operate in many fields, including investment banking, capital market services, and asset management.

However, their activities do not always have the best interests of investors at heart, and sometimes they tend to drive ultra-short-term trading to increase their fee revenue. This may conflict with Benjamin Graham's philosophy of long-term value investing.


(2) Impact on investors

Challenges to Long-Term Value Investing

1. Ultra-short-term trading and long-term value

Global securities firms offer various financial products and services, often attracting ultra-short-term trading. These trades, driven by market noise, may conflict with Graham's long-term value investing philosophy.

Focusing on short-term fluctuations can cause investors to overlook long-term intrinsic value.

2. Fees and costs

Frequent trading through global brokerage firms can result in increased fees and expenses. Ultra-short-term trades, in particular, incur high transaction costs, which can diminish long-term profitability.

Graham's philosophy emphasizes minimizing costs and seeking stable returns over time, highlighting the importance of carefully considering transaction costs and fees associated with global brokerage firms.

Bank

(3) Famous global brokerage firms

Global Financial Services Firms Overview Role
Goldman Sachs

What it is: Goldman Sachs is a global investment bank, engaged in stock and bond trading, capital markets services, and asset management.

It is one of the most influential firms on Wall Street, playing a key role in mergers and acquisitions, IPOs, and more.

Role: It provides companies and governments with fundraising options and offers investment opportunities to investors.

Additionally, through its wealth management services, it manages the assets of individual and institutional investors to help them achieve their financial goals.

Morgan Stanley

What it is: Morgan Stanley is a global investment banking and wealth management firm offering investment banking, capital markets, asset management, and trust services.

It specializes in wealth management for private and institutional clients.

Role: It provides capital raising and financial advisory services to businesses and acts as an intermediary in financial markets.

Moreover, it offers customized wealth management services to clients, helping them create long-term value based on their financial situations and goals.

JPMorgan Chase

What it is: JPMorgan Chase is a global financial services company providing investment banking, commercial banking, wealth management, and personal banking services.

As one of the largest banks globally, it offers a wide range of financial services and has an extensive international network.

Role: Through its financial services, it facilitates liquidity in financial markets and aids businesses and governments in fundraising.

Its wealth management division manages portfolios for individual and institutional investors, offering tailored investment solutions to meet their needs.

(4) Bottom line.

While investors should take advantage of the services offered by global brokerage firms, they should remember Graham's value investing philosophy. An approach that focuses on long-term value and is not swayed by short-term market fluctuations is important.

It also requires careful consideration of fees and expenses, and in-depth analysis and discretion when making investment decisions. With this approach, investors can utilize the services of a global brokerage firm to their advantage.


4. Investment banking

Investment banks are institutions that play an important role in the capital market. They help companies raise funds by issuing stocks or bonds, and participate in the process of acquiring and selling them.

However, historically there have been incidents where investment banks sold low-quality new stocks to the public at overvalued prices, resulting in large losses for investors.

(1) Example of low-quality new stocks

Example of Low-Quality New Stocks Context Lesson Learned
Case of 1960-1961

In 1960-1961, companies in the 'electronics' and 'aerospace' fields especially received great attention.

At this time, investment in the defense and aerospace industries was increasing due to the impact of the Cold War, and demand for electronic devices was also growing rapidly.

Accordingly, related companies attracted the attention of investors in the stock market, and some companies took advantage of this opportunity to issue new shares whose investment value was evaluated to be higher than the actual value.

Investors learned the importance of carefully analyzing the true value of companies before making investment decisions.

Market optimism and excitement can lead to overvalued stocks, resulting in losses for investors.

Case of 1968-1969

In 1968-1969, there was an investment craze for ‘high-growth technology stocks’.

This was a time when new technology companies, called 'high-growth stocks' or 'concept stocks', attracted attention, and investors focused their investments on expectations that these companies would grow significantly in the future.

However, many companies were overvalued regardless of their actual value, which later caused their stock prices to plummet, resulting in heavy losses for investors.

Investors were reminded of the importance of analyzing a company's actual value and potential rather than being swayed by market hype.

This period underscored the necessity of information transparency, especially for retail investors with limited access to information.


(2) Current situation of global investment banks

Changes in Global Investment Banking Description
Strengthening regulation

Regulations such as Basel III, the US Dodd-Frank Act, and the European Union's MiFID II have been introduced to increase transparency and strengthen investor protection.

These regulations require investment banks to maintain more capital, improve risk management practices, and enhance transparency.

Advances in technology

Technological advancements, including algorithmic trading, have enabled investment banks to operate more efficiently.

These advancements increase market efficiency, reduce transaction costs, and provide investors with better access to information.

Increased investor education

Investors are becoming more educated and have greater access to information, enabling them to make more informed decisions.

This increased investor education helps investors understand financial products and make decisions that align with their investment goals and risk tolerance.

Despite these changes, investors should exercise caution and avoid being swayed by market trends.

It's important to carefully consider advice and products offered by investment banks and make decisions that are in line with individual investment objectives.

The global investment banking landscape is dominated by a few major players, who offer a wide range of financial services and have a significant global presence.

(3) Famous investment bank

Global Investment Banks Description
Goldman Sachs

Goldman Sachs is a leading global investment bank offering services in investment banking, financial services, asset management, and investment management.

It is renowned for its specialized services, deep market insight, and expertise in corporate mergers and acquisitions (M&A) advisory work.

JPMorgan Chase

JPMorgan Chase is one of the largest investment banks globally, providing corporate finance, investment banking, asset management, and retail financial services.

It operates in various markets leveraging its strong capital base and global networks.

Morgan Stanley

Morgan Stanley is a global investment bank specializing in investment banking, asset management, and corporate finance advisory services.

It is particularly known for its expertise in corporate mergers and acquisitions advisory, securities issuance, and asset management for high-net-worth individuals.

Barclays

Barclays is a large investment bank headquartered in the UK, offering a wide range of financial services internationally.

It operates in corporate finance, investment banking, asset management, and retail banking. Barclays has a strong presence in European and American markets.

Deutsche Bank

Deutsche Bank, Germany's largest bank, provides global investment banking, asset management, and corporate finance services.

It holds significant influence in the European-centric financial market, especially in corporate mergers and acquisitions advisory and asset management within Europe.

These global investment banks compete in the global financial markets with their own unique strategies and strengths.